Watertown, Jefferson County Criminal Defense Lawyer

Home » Watertown, Jefferson County Criminal Defense Lawyer

Here To Guide You Through Your Domestic Violence Charge

Officials aggressively pursue criminal cases, and statistics reveal their relentless efforts. According to arrest data compiled by the Wisconsin Department of Justice (WI DOJ), law enforcement officers arrest more than 201,000 people every year statewide. Almost 3,300 people face charges in Jefferson County, including arrests by the Watertown Police Department and the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office.

If you face criminal charges in Wisconsin, it’s essential to retain skilled legal representation as early in the process as possible. Our team at Nicholson Goetz & Otis, S.C., is prepared to protect your rights at all stages. Please contact us to set up a free, 30-minute consultation with a Watertown, Jefferson County criminal defense lawyer.

Support with Many Types of Criminal Cases

Partnering with a skilled criminal defense attorney is crucial for both felony and misdemeanor cases, as well as traffic violations. Incarceration, fines, and collateral consequences for your life can be significant. Felonies in Wisconsin are more severe offenses, often resulting in long-term consequences, including lengthy prison sentences and substantial fines. Misdemeanors are less severe but can still lead to jail time and fines. Plus, you’ll have a permanent criminal record.

Our criminal defense lawyers who serve Watertown have years of combined experience handling a wide array of criminal cases. We offer dedicated, personalized legal support to protect your rights and strategize for the best possible outcome. We’re ready to defend:

  • Homicide and violent crimes, including assault and domestic violence
  • Drug offenses for possession, distribution, and manufacturing of controlled substances
  • Sexual assault, rape, and other sex-related crimes
  • OWI and traffic violations
In addition, Nicholson Goetz & Otis, S.C., has an extensive background defending those accused of federal crimes. Our criminal defense team in Watertown, Wisconsin, is committed to delivering quality legal representation for all our clients. Our results speak for themselves.

Steps in the Wisconsin Criminal Process

It’s helpful to review some basics about the criminal process if you’ve been arrested for a crime in Jefferson County. Your rights are critical at every stage of the case, starting from the investigation and arrest. It’s important to have an attorney to handle all communications with law enforcement. You have the right to remain silent, and you must exercise it to avoid making statements that could harm your interests.
Once you enter the criminal process, there are proceedings in court before a judge. The specifics vary, but the steps may include:

Arraignment

During this initial appearance in court, the judge announces the formal charges and asks you to enter a plea. Your options include a guilty, not guilty, or no-contest plea. Practically speaking, the only plea that is ever entered at an arraignment is not guilty.

Pretrial and Motions

In addition to regular status conferences, the pretrial phase may involve filing motions. A motion is a formal, written request to the court to decide on a critical issue in the case. Our lawyers will pursue any motion practice that benefits your position, such as motions to dismiss or suppress evidence.

Trial

Before a judge or jury as finder of fact, both sides present evidence and arguments during your trial. This phase is critical, as it determines guilt versus acquittal of the charges. You can count on a defense attorney to engage in an array of finely-tuned tactics through arguments, evidence, and exhibits.

Sentencing

After a conviction at trial or guilty plea via plea bargain, the court moves to sentencing. Legal representation is critically important to minimize the impact of the criminal penalties. A person convicted of a criminal offense may face:
  • Jail time
  • Incarceration in prison
  • Fines
  • Restitution
  • Suspension of driver’s license or professional licenses

Defenses to Criminal Charges in Wisconsin

There are multiple strategies to fight the accusations in a criminal case. Initially, your lawyer may have grounds to argue that the prosecution has failed to meet the burden of proof beyond a reasonable doubt. This tactic could result in a reduction or dismissal of the charges.
Plus, police can be overzealous in their efforts to control crime. Their misconduct during an investigation or arrest could violate your constitutional rights, amounting to an unlawful search or seizure. When officers fail to comply with the Fourth Amendment, any evidence turned up during a search and seizure is inadmissible in court.
Guidance from an experienced criminal defense lawyer is essential when you must address violations of your constitutional rights. You must raise this issue by motion, a process that is subject to meticulous court procedural rules. If successful in convincing the court to toss illegally obtained evidence, the prosecutor may not have enough proof to meet its burden.
Some additional defenses may include:
  • Challenging the legality of the arrest
  • Questioning the validity of evidence
  • Establishing an alibi
  • Self-defense
With a thorough understanding of Wisconsin’s criminal laws and procedures, your criminal defense attorney in Watertown will work tirelessly to craft a defense that protects your freedom, wallet, and future.

Other Options to Resolve Criminal Charges

In many Wisconsin criminal cases, plea bargains offer a way to resolve charges without going to trial. A plea bargain involves negotiating with the prosecution to reduce the charges or penalties in exchange for a guilty plea. This option can result in a more favorable outcome, such as reduced jail time or fines. Our team will thoroughly evaluate whether these options are in your best interests. A plea agreement may not be advisable if you have a solid defense.

Wisconsin’s Deferred Adjudication Program (DAP) enables eligible individuals to avoid a conviction on their record. Under this program, you can work for a dismissal of the charges by successfully completing the requirements set by the court during a probationary period. As a result, you will not carry the long-term consequences of a criminal history.

Guidance from a knowledgeable criminal defense lawyer helps you leverage a plea bargain or participation in DAP. This strategic approach can help you minimize the impact of criminal charges on your life and future.

How a Skilled Criminal Defense Attorney Serves Your Needs

When you must fight criminal charges in Wisconsin, a skilled criminal defense attorney provides guidance and direction to help you make informed decisions about your case. From the moment we take on your case, you can trust the criminal defense lawyers at the Nicholson Goetz & Otis, S.C., to manage all mission-critical tasks, such as:
  • Conducting a thorough investigation into the charges
  • Collecting and evaluating evidence
  • Interviewing witnesses
  • Identifying legal issues or defenses to challenge the prosecution’s case

Throughout the proceedings, we will file necessary motions, represent you in court appearances, and work to negotiate favorable plea deals when appropriate. Our team knows the stress caused by criminal charges, so we will keep you informed and prepared, offering guidance and advocacy every step of the way.

Watertown, WI Criminal Defense Frequently Asked Questions

Criminal charges lead to a lot of questions. Below are some of the most common ones our law office receives. Nicholson Goetz & Otis, S.C., is available to answer any additional questions and provide guidance tailored to your situation when you contact us today.

What should I do immediately after being arrested in Watertown, WI?

If law enforcement arrests you, remain calm and exercise your right to remain silent. Don’t discuss your case with police or other officials without a lawyer present. When you contact our criminal defense attorneys right away, that allows us to investigate the arrest and protect your rights from the beginning.

How do I find out what the prosecution charged me with?

Charges are formally presented during the arraignment in court, and your lawyer will likely help you find out even before the hearing. At the arraignment, the judge reads the complaint and asks you to enter a plea. Even if the paperwork seems confusing, the court record will show the exact criminal statute cited. Your attorney can explain the specific elements of the charges, possible penalties, and whether they’re felonies or misdemeanors.

What is the difference between a felony and a misdemeanor in Wisconsin?

Felonies are the most serious crimes and can lead to lengthy prison sentences. They often have lasting consequences for employment and civil rights, even after your sentence is complete. Misdemeanors carry shorter jail time, lower fines, and generally less severe long-term impacts. Both categories, however, result in a criminal record. A Watertown criminal defense lawyer can help determine whether the charges might be reduced or dismissed.

Can I represent myself in a criminal case in Watertown?

You have the right to self-representation, but it can be very risky. Criminal proceedings involve complex rules of evidence and procedures. Our experienced criminal defense attorneys serving Watertown can identify legal issues that may not be obvious and advocate on your behalf both in court and during negotiations. Representing yourself could limit your ability to challenge evidence or preserve your legal rights.

How do plea bargains work in Wisconsin?

A plea bargain is an agreement with the prosecution to resolve your case without going to trial. You might plead guilty in exchange for reduced charges or penalties, like a shorter jail sentence or smaller fines. Your lawyer will review any offer carefully. The goal is to weigh any potential benefits against your defense options.

It’s important to remember that a plea bargain is not automatic, and that you should only take the deal if it’s in your best interests.

Can evidence be excluded from my case?

It’s not guaranteed, but it’s common. Evidence can be suppressed if law enforcement collected it in violation of your Constitutional rights – often through an unlawful search or seizure or improper arrest. Filing a motion to suppress can lead to the court throwing out the unlawfully collected evidence. If enough key evidence is excluded, the prosecution may lack proof to proceed, which can lead to reduced charges or dismissal.

Can I get bail or release before trial?

Often, but it depends on multiple factors. Bail decisions factor in the exact charges and how serious they are. Wisconsin judges will also consider your criminal history and whether you’re a flight risk. Our law firm can argue for reasonable bail terms and explain any bond conditions.

Will past convictions affect my current case?

They certainly can. Past offenses do not automatically determine the outcome, but they are a factor in charges and sentencing. In some instances, they can affect your eligibility for diversion programs. Our law firm can identify possible challenges and argue for a fair outcome in court.

Speak to a Wisconsin Criminal Defense Lawyer Today

Don’t delay in reaching out for legal help if you’re facing criminal charges in Watertown or Jefferson County. Contact Nicholson Goetz & Otis, S.C., right away to discuss your case with a skilled attorney. Please go online or call us at (608) 336-5445 to schedule your free 30-minute initial consultation. We can arrange off-site, evening, and weekend meetings by appointment. Our team is ready to fight for your rights and deliver the strong legal defense support you deserve.
From the North:
  • Take US-151 S towards Madison
  • Continue onto E Washington Ave
  • Turn right onto N Webster St
  • Turn left onto E Mifflin St
  • Destination will be on the right
From the South:
  • Take US-151 N towards Madison
  • Turn left onto E Wilson St and continue onto King St
  • Turn right onto E Mifflin St
  • Destination will be on the right
From the East:
  • Take US-14 W towards Madison
  • Continue onto US-18
  • Take the exit and merge onto US-151 N
  • Turn left onto E Wilson St and continue onto King St
  • Turn right onto E Mifflin St
  • Destination will be on the right
From the West:
  • Take US-18E towards Madison 
  • Take the exit and merge onto US-151 N
  • Turn left onto E Wilson St and continue onto King St
  • Turn right onto E Mifflin St
  • Destination will be on the right